In contemporary Britain, public demonstration is no longer a basic freedom. Rather, it has become a privilege that those in power grant or deny as they see fit. This constitutes the implication of proposed measures that the current government is advancing, which would determine the timing and location demonstrations can take place, with potential imprisonment for those who defy these limitations.
Gradual Weakening of Civil Liberties
Previous administrations had already undermined this essential right: the former Conservative government had granted law enforcement sweeping new authorities, which international human rights organizations had condemned as "significant and undue limitations" on democratic freedoms. Collectively, these progressive attacks on liberty have practically abolished the hard-won right to public demonstration.
Using Atrocity to Justify Crackdown
The most recent restrictive measures are being defended by referring to last week's heinous anti-Jewish assault on a Manchester mosque. We can all agree on widespread consensus that the safety of Jewish communities in Britain must be protected. However, employing this atrocity as a justification to suppress opposition is not only disconnected to that duty but distorts it.
"When you can't set boundaries at mass killing, you likely can't draw the line at democratic principles," observed a well-known American author, whose words that applies equally for the present administration.
Historical Perspective of Protest
Consider Britain's rich history of protest and direct action against racism and fascism, from the 1936 Battle of Cable Street to after World War II Jewish groups opposing fascism and the 1970s demonstrations against the far-right organization. Many of these early protesters were labeled as extremists in their era, even while they were fighting for the freedoms of marginalized groups.
Current Reality
In today's complicated landscape, here's what's actually occurring: The Israeli government – a sovereign nation – is perpetrating acts that international bodies have characterized as systematic destruction. Its warfare have led the International Criminal Court to release legal indictments against Israel's prime minister and his former defense minister.
International public opinion has changed significantly against Israel's violent actions. In Britain, a substantial majority of the public believe Israel has likely committed international law violations. Most people would endorse a total prohibition on weapons exports to the nation, and approve the arrest of the Israeli leader.
Silencing Dissent
Having essentially lost the argument, Israel's supporters are now exploiting a despicable anti-Jewish attack to try to silence a popular campaign against a ethical disaster. The British government seems involved in this attempt. Ministers have not enacted extensive restrictions on Israel and have allowed arms exports to proceed.
People who are demonstrating against the erasure of Gaza have been characterized as hateful extremists. Yet there's a significant reason why there hasn't been a more extensive suppression on these protesters until now: very limited protesters have made truly offensive statements about Jewish people, giving law enforcement minimal reason to intervene.
Dangerous Conflation
Merging Jewish identity with the actions of the Israeli state is not only manipulative but also dangerous. The official definition of antisemitism, accepted by the British government and many organizations, has been rightly questioned for potentially restricting legitimate criticism of Israel. However, there should be universal agreement about one of its key examples: that "making Jewish people collectively responsible for decisions of the state of Israel" constitutes antisemitism.
Escalating Restrictions
This is why we've arrived at a situation where law enforcement can propose that protests criticizing Israel's policies should be canceled because they might "inadvertently or deliberately" endorse antisemitism. Similarly, political figures have declared that acknowledgment of Palestine as a nation has made organizations "complicit" in alleged abuse faced by Jewish communities.
Inconsistent Treatment
On the same day as the religious center assault, the Israeli military killed dozens of Palestinian civilians in Gaza – adding to the horrific toll from two years of daily atrocities that have taken many thousands of human lives. British politicians and news organizations have barely concealed the minimal importance they assign to Palestinian existence. This represents one of the most brazen demonstrations of discrimination in contemporary society.
Crossing Thresholds
Our government has already crossed a dangerous threshold by banning a specific activist group, a non-violent, human rights-focused activist collective. Multiple thousands of British demonstrators have been arrested, primarily for carrying signs opposing mass killing and endorsing the proscribed group. Many of those detained are pensioners; including a retired priest and the child of a World War II genocide survivor.
Global Comparisons
It's not difficult to see where this path leads. In the United States, political leaders helped demonize pro-Palestinian protests: a ex-political leader implied that some were "linked with" foreign governments, while the sitting leader characterized such demonstrations as anti-Jewish. In taking these actions, they contributed to normalizing the authoritarian crackdown on such protests – and on freedom of expression in general.
Looking Ahead
If a hard-right government comes to power, it would be given sweeping powers to suppress dissent. What might a new administration do with this repressive toolkit? Our forebears struggled, endured hardship and sacrificed their lives to establish our liberties. We may eventually regret how easily we permitted them to be eroded.